Institute for Advanced Materials Research Press Institute for Advanced Materials Research Press

Search

Search results:
Uncertainty Quantification for ML Interatomic Potentials: A Review of Methods, Hidden Assumptions, and Unresolved Questions
Uncertainty quantification (UQ) has become indispensable for the trustworthy deployment of machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs) in materials science and molecular modeling, where predictions of energies, forces, and derived properties directly inform high-stakes decisions in materials discovery, long-time-scale molecular dynamics, and autonomous design workflows. Without reliable uncertainty estimates, MLIPs risk propagating errors that compromise simulation stability, mislead experimental prioritization, or produce unphysical results in extrapolation regimes critical to novel alloy or molecular discovery. This review synthesizes the literature on UQ methods specifically developed for or applied to MLIPs, drawing exclusively from the compiled reference set to provide a focused, critical overview of progress during this formative period. The scope is deliberately restricted to UQ techniques for interatomic potentials themselves (including GAP, DeepMD, ANI-series, SchNet-derived, and E(3)-equivariant models such as NequIP), excluding standalone ML property prediction unless the method directly supports force-field uncertainty. A systematic taxonomy organizes existing approaches into five methodological families—Bayesian and probabilistic methods, ensemble methods, Gaussian process and kernel methods, conformal prediction and frequentist methods, and heuristic and ad hoc methods—highlighting their distinct mathematical foundations and practical implementations in MLIP contexts. Hidden assumptions pervading these families are identified and dissected, including independence of atomic errors, Gaussianity of predictive distributions, homoscedasticity across chemical space, kernel-imposed smoothness in Gaussian processes, approximation quality in variational or Monte-Carlo inference, and exchangeability in conformal frameworks. These assumptions frequently remain unstated yet profoundly influence calibration and reliability when MLIPs are deployed in production simulations. Unresolved questions are articulated with precision: how to treat correlated uncertainties along molecular-dynamics trajectories, the absence of a true ground-truth uncertainty given DFT approximations, the prohibitive computational overhead of scalable UQ, evaluation under distribution shift, vectorial uncertainty for forces rather than scalar energies, detection of physical inconsistencies, and hierarchical fusion of model, data, and ab-initio uncertainties. Future outlook points toward integrated UQ-driven active learning, force-aware uncertainty representations, and hybrid methods that balance calibration, sharpness, and efficiency for next-generation autonomous materials engineering.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 July 2022 | Article: 9

Graph Neural Networks for Periodic Crystals: A Systematic Review of Representational Trade-Offs and Hidden Assumptions
Graph neural networks (GNNs) have transformed the modeling of periodic crystalline materials, enabling rapid prediction of formation energies, band gaps, elastic moduli, and interatomic forces directly from atomic coordinates. Early architectures including CGCNN and MEGNet established that message-passing on crystal graphs could rival density-functional theory (DFT) in speed while maintaining high accuracy for scalar properties. Subsequent advances introduced directional message passing (DimeNet, GemNet), equivariant architectures (E(3)-equivariant networks, MACE), graph attention mechanisms, and multi-scale approaches—each embodying distinct representational choices regarding node-edge features, symmetry handling, and information propagation. This systematic review synthesizes the literature not around incremental performance gains but around the fundamental representational trade-offs and hidden assumptions that govern model behavior in periodic systems. A taxonomy is developed organized by invariance versus equivariance, distance-only versus directional versus angular features, shallow versus deep message passing, and global pooling strategies. Four core trade-offs are analyzed: invariance against equivariance, local against global information capture, model depth against over-smoothing, and computational cost against expressivity. Beyond these, seven rarely articulated hidden assumptions are exposed—cutoff-radius sufficiency, primitive-cell representativeness, distance-only edge sufficiency, global-pooling adequacy, cubic-crystal benchmark bias, DFT-label perfection, and i.i.d. data assumptions—each critically limiting generalization to real-world materials discovery contexts. Empirical comparisons consistently favor newer architectures on standard benchmarks yet rarely isolate the contribution of individual design choices or report failure modes for low-symmetry crystals, extrapolation tasks, or long-range physics. Persistent gaps remain in long-range interaction modeling, uncertainty quantification, extrapolation capability, multi-property trade-offs, and interpretability. By reframing the crystal GNN literature through these lenses, this review offers a structured roadmap for future architecture development that prioritizes robustness and transparency over raw benchmark scores.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2023 | Article: 14

Equivariant Neural Networks for Materials: A Review of Architectural Innovations and What They Actually Guarantee
Equivariant neural networks have emerged as a transformative paradigm in computational materials science and molecular modeling, embedding rotational, translational, and permutational symmetries directly into the network architecture rather than learning them from data.A rapid sequence of innovations—from Tensor Field Networks to NequIP , MACE, Allegro, and the e3nn framework —has produced architectures that deliver state-of-the-art accuracy in interatomic potential prediction while dramatically reducing data requirements compared with invariant or non-symmetric baselines. This review synthesizes the architectural lineage of E(3)- and SE(3)-equivariant models developed specifically for materials and molecular systems, critically examines the theoretical guarantees provided by group and representation theory (universality, sample-complexity reduction, exact symmetry preservation, and conservation-law compliance), and contrasts these guarantees with empirical outcomes reported on standard atomistic benchmarks. Although equivariant networks provably approximate any continuous equivariant function and enforce exact roto-translational symmetry by construction, their practical advantages are most pronounced in the low-data regime and for vectorial properties such as forces. Limitations persist in composition-space extrapolation, long-range interaction modeling, magnetic systems, and computational scaling for higher-order equivariance. By systematically cataloguing these guarantees and gaps across 45 peer-reviewed contributions published 2017–2023, the review identifies a clear disconnect between mathematical assurances derived under idealized assumptions and the realities of finite datasets, complex material compositions, and large-scale simulations. The analysis concludes with open questions on optimal equivariance order, multi-group symmetry handling, and rigorous generalization bounds for continuous groups, offering a roadmap for future theoretical and practical advances in data-driven materials engineering.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 July 2023 | Article: 21

Benchmarking Practices for ML Interatomic Potentials: A Critical Review of Methodological Pitfalls and What Was Missed (2017–2023)
Benchmarking has become central to the development of machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs), yet the epistemic reliability of reported comparisons remains insufficiently scrutinized. This review synthesizes prevailing practices and demonstrates that current evaluation protocols systematically misrepresent model progress. A coherent taxonomy of methodological failure emerges, spanning opaque data handling, structurally flawed train–test partitioning, restricted metric selection, weak baseline construction, limited reproducibility, and the near absence of extrapolation analysis. Under these conditions, widely cited performance indicators—such as sub-10 meV/atom energy MAE or sub-0.1 eV/Å force RMSE—primarily capture interpolation within constrained training distributions, offering limited insight into generalization, dynamical stability, or deployment viability. A related deficiency lies in the systematic exclusion of physically and computationally salient regimes, including long-range interactions, finite-temperature behavior, low-symmetry and disordered structures, calibrated uncertainty, defect-rich configurations, and explicit cost–accuracy trade-offs. Existing benchmark suites, including Materials Project–derived datasets, QM9 adaptations, COMP6, and bespoke collections, inherit these constraints, reinforcing an evaluative paradigm that privileges narrow optimization over robust, application-relevant performance. Recasting benchmark outcomes as contingent on methodological design rather than intrinsic model capability reveals how evaluation choices implicitly structure model rankings. In response, this work advances a set of directly implementable standards: diversified splitting strategies, distribution-aware multi-metric reporting, transparent baseline inclusion, controlled extrapolation regimes, complete reproducibility artifacts, and normalized cost accounting. Aligning benchmarking practice with these principles is necessary to transition from incremental leaderboard gains toward reliable and transferable interatomic potentials for materials discovery.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2024 | Article: 28

Domain Adaptation for Cross-Composition Materials Prediction: A Review of Trade-Offs and Unvalidated Assumptions (2017–2024)
Domain adaptation has emerged as a promising strategy for cross-composition materials prediction, where models trained on one compositional regime are transferred to chemically distinct but related target domains. This review examines the literature from 2017 to 2024 on domain adaptation in materials informatics, with a specific focus on prediction tasks spanning binary, ternary, quaternary, and high-entropy systems. It argues that although transfer-based methods are increasingly used to reduce dependence on expensive first-principles calculations and scarce experimental measurements, their application often rests on theoretical assumptions that remain untested in materials contexts. Across the reviewed studies, six recurrent assumptions are identified: shared feature space, covariate shift only, sufficient source–target overlap, label-function stability, sample independence, and availability of target-domain data. The review shows that these assumptions are fragile under composition-induced shifts, where new bonding environments, structural prototypes, and electronic behaviors frequently alter the underlying prediction problem. It further synthesizes the field into six methodological categories—feature alignment, adversarial adaptation, reweighting, fine-tuning, multi-source adaptation, and unsupervised adaptation—and evaluates their strengths, vulnerabilities, and suitability under varying similarity regimes. Five core trade-offs structure current practice, particularly those involving performance versus negative transfer, simplicity versus flexibility, and theory versus empirical reliability. The review also identifies persistent gaps, including the lack of standardized benchmarks, weak similarity quantification, limited reporting of failure cases, and insufficient evaluation under true extrapolation. In response, it proposes a validation and reporting framework centered on pre-adaptation diagnostics, explicit similarity scoring, comparative baselines, negative-transfer reporting, and computational transparency. Overall, the review concludes that domain adaptation is most reliable as a data-efficiency tool within compositionally similar neighborhoods, but remains brittle and potentially misleading when applied across chemically distant domains without diagnostic validation.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 July 2024 | Article: 35

Position: Reproducible Workflows for Data-Driven Materials Engineering — From Data Provenance to Model Cards
Reproducibility has emerged as a critical bottleneck in data-driven materials engineering, particularly as graph neural networks (GNNs) and associated uncertainty quantification (UQ) methods are increasingly embedded in high-stakes discovery pipelines. While advances in conformal prediction, Bayesian inference, and ensemble techniques have improved predictive reliability, their practical deployment remains constrained by fragmented workflows, opaque data provenance, and inconsistent reporting standards. This review reframes uncertainty-aware materials modeling through the lens of reproducible workflows, tracing the pipeline from dataset construction and curation to model training, calibration, and deployment. Drawing on peer-reviewed studies, we integrate methodological advances in UQ with emerging practices in data governance, experiment tracking, and model documentation. The analysis reveals that uncertainty estimates are only as trustworthy as the workflows that generate them: biases in dataset composition, undocumented preprocessing steps, and inconsistent calibration protocols systematically undermine reliability, even when state-of-the-art UQ methods are applied. We argue that reproducibility must be treated as a first-class design constraint, requiring standardized data provenance tracking, version-controlled training pipelines, and model cards that explicitly document uncertainty behavior, calibration performance, and failure modes. By linking UQ theory with reproducible systems design, this work establishes a framework for trustworthy materials graph learning in which uncertainty is not merely computed but auditable, interpretable, and transferable across applications.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2025 | Article: 42

Multi-Fidelity Learning in High-Throughput Materials Screening: A Review of Surrogate Strategies and Their Broken Promises
Multi-fidelity learning has been positioned as a transformative tool for high-throughput materials screening, offering the ability to fuse inexpensive low-fidelity data—generated from classical force fields, tight-binding models, or CALPHAD thermodynamics—with costly high-fidelity calculations such as density functional theory (DFT). The central premise is straightforward: surrogate models can learn systematic discrepancies between fidelity levels, delivering near-DFT accuracy at a fraction of the computational expense and thereby enabling the rapid exploration of vast compositional and structural spaces that would otherwise remain inaccessible. A substantial body of work in journals including npj Computational Materials, Machine Learning: Science and Technology, Digital Discovery, Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, Journal of Chemical Physics, and Nature Machine Intelligence has explored this paradigm through linear corrections, Gaussian process discrepancy modeling, neural network transfer learning, multi-fidelity Bayesian optimization, ensemble approaches, and hierarchical correction chains. Yet the promises remain largely unfulfilled. Despite hundreds of reported case studies, the literature reveals few, if any, experimentally validated novel materials discovered solely through multi-fidelity acceleration. Efficiency gains rarely exceed 2–5× in realistic workflows, uncertainty estimates are frequently miscalibrated outside training domains, and extrapolation to chemically distinct regions consistently collapses to the accuracy of the underlying low-fidelity baseline. Overclaims regarding order-of-magnitude cost reductions, guaranteed high-fidelity fidelity, and accelerated discovery have not materialized in practice. This review provides the first systematic synthesis of the 34 peer-reviewed publications that directly address multi-fidelity surrogate strategies in materials screening. It categorizes surrogate architectures, contrasts theoretical assumptions with empirical performance, inventories six recurring broken promises, and distills actionable lessons from the collective evidence. By foregrounding the persistent gaps between theory and application—non-stationary bias, limited transferability, and evaluation practices that favor interpolation over genuine discovery—this work offers a sober roadmap for future research in computational and data-driven materials engineering. The field must move beyond optimistic benchmarks toward honest reporting of real-world discovery metrics if multi-fidelity learning is to fulfill even a modest fraction of its original vision.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 July 2025 | Article: 49

Out-of-Distribution Generalization in Materials AI: A Systematic Review of Domain Shift, Robustness, and What Remains Unsolved
Out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization remains one of the most pressing barriers to the reliable deployment of artificial intelligence in materials science. Although machine-learning models now routinely achieve sub-0.1 eV/atom errors on in-distribution test sets for formation energies, band gaps, and elastic moduli, these same models frequently collapse when confronted with materials that lie outside the training distribution. Real-world materials discovery and process optimization demand predictions for unseen compositions, novel crystal prototypes, altered thermodynamic conditions, and non-equilibrium dynamical regimes—scenarios that constitute domain shift rather than simple interpolation. This systematic review synthesizes the literature on OOD generalization in materials AI drawing exclusively peer-reviewed publications from high-impact venues including npj Computational Materials, Digital Discovery, Machine Learning: Science and Technology, and Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation. We identify four primary types of domain shift—compositional, structural, thermodynamic, and dynamical—and introduce a fifth multi-dimensional category that captures the realistic superposition of shifts encountered in practice. Current methodological families are critically assessed: domain adaptation (distribution alignment), invariant learning (IRM and Group DRO), physics-informed and symmetry-aware data augmentation, uncertainty quantification for OOD detection, and extrapolation-aware architectures (equivariant networks, multi-fidelity models, and generative priors). Empirical findings across the corpus reveal a consistent pattern: modest gains (20–50 % error reduction) are achievable for small, single-axis shifts, yet performance degrades sharply—and often catastrophically—for large compositional jumps, prototype changes, or combined multi-dimensional shifts. No method currently delivers reliable extrapolation beyond the convex hull of the training manifold. Key gaps persist. The community lacks standardized OOD benchmarks with controlled shift axes, theoretical guarantees for extrapolation remain underdeveloped, and conditional (per-input) robustness guarantees are almost entirely absent. Evaluation metrics are inconsistent, rendering cross-paper comparisons unreliable. This review therefore provides not only a taxonomy and synthesis but also a forward-looking identification of unsolved problems that must be addressed before materials AI can transition from laboratory demonstration to industrial reliability. OOD generalization in materials AI is no longer an optional research direction; it is the central unsolved challenge that will determine the field’s practical impact over the next decade.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 July 2025 | Article: 56

Graph-Based Learning for Disordered Systems: A Review of Amorphous, Liquid, and Glassy Materials
Graph-based machine learning has reached maturity for crystalline materials, where periodic boundary conditions and fixed unit cells allow efficient message passing and property prediction. Disordered systems—amorphous solids, liquids, glasses, and polymers—represent the next frontier. These materials dominate everyday technologies, from smartphone screens and optical fibers to electrolytes in batteries and structural alloys, yet they lack the translational symmetry that simplifies graph construction in crystals. This review synthesizes exactly 35 peer-reviewed publications from 2017 to 2025 that apply graph-based learning, graph neural networks (GNNs), and related data-driven methods to non-crystalline materials. The selected works span key target journals including npj Computational Materials, Physical Review B, Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, Machine Learning: Science and Technology, and Physical Review Materials. The review is organized around a taxonomy of five classes of disordered systems: amorphous solids, liquids, glasses (including supercooled liquids), polymers, and crystals with substitutional disorder. It identifies seven core challenges that distinguish disordered systems from crystals: absence of periodic boundaries, variable graph sizes, heterogeneous local atomic environments, the critical role of medium-range order (5–15 Å), dynamic graph evolution in liquids, lack of standardized benchmarks, and prohibitive computational cost for large simulation boxes. Current methodological approaches are grouped into six categories—local descriptors (non-graph), graph pooling for size invariance, multi-scale GNNs, equivariant architectures, temporal GNNs for liquids, and transfer learning from crystal data—each evaluated for strengths, limitations, and empirical performance on properties such as density, elastic moduli, glass-forming ability, relaxation dynamics, and defect identification. Despite notable progress, three persistent gaps remain: limited size transferability across simulation-box lengths, inadequate capture of medium-range structural correlations, and under-development of methods for dynamic properties. By critically analyzing these 35 studies, this review provides a systematic framework for graph-based learning in disordered materials and highlights open problems that must be solved before these techniques can achieve the same reliability and scalability already demonstrated for crystals. The field stands at an inflection point: continued innovation in graph representations and benchmarking will determine whether graph-based methods can fully unlock predictive modeling for the disordered materials that underpin modern technology.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2026 | Article: 58

Foundation Models and LLMs for Materials Science: A Review of Prompting, Fine-Tuning, and What Does Not Transfer
Foundation models and large language models (LLMs) are rapidly entering materials science, offering new interfaces for property prediction, synthesis planning, and literature mining. This review synthesizes some peer-reviewed publications, focusing on foundation models pre-trained on crystals, molecules, and text, as well as LLM-based approaches for materials tasks. Three primary use cases emerge: (1) property prediction from compositional or structural descriptions, (2) synthesis recipe generation, and (3) extraction of structured data from scientific text. Methods span zero-shot prompting, few-shot prompting, chain-of-thought reasoning, retrieval-augmented generation, full fine-tuning, parameter-efficient fine-tuning, and embedding-based adaptation. What transfers effectively includes generic chemical knowledge, structure–text relationships, qualitative trends, similarity search, and literature extraction. In contrast, what does not transfer includes quantitative property prediction to experimental accuracy, extrapolation beyond pre-training distributions, crystal stability assessment, physics-based reasoning, and hallucination-free synthesis planning. Despite promising demonstrations in common materials, LLMs and foundation models still lag behind specialized graph neural networks in quantitative tasks and fail on compositional or structural novelty. This review provides a systematic taxonomy of applications, a critical analysis of prompting and fine-tuning strategies, and a clear delineation of transfer limitations. Gaps remain in uncertainty quantification, multimodal data scarcity, and rigorous benchmarking against non-LLM baselines. Recommendations for practitioners and developers emphasize realistic expectations and hybrid human–AI workflows to accelerate materials discovery without over-reliance on ungrounded predictions.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2026 | Article: 65

A Decade of Data-Driven Materials Engineering: Progress, Remaining Gaps, and Unlearned Lessons
Machine learning has transformed materials engineering through graph neural networks, equivariant architectures, generative models, and early autonomous laboratories. These advances enabled accurate property prediction, data-efficient force fields, and initial inverse design of inorganic crystals, supported by community databases such as the Materials Project and JARVIS. Generative frameworks now propose novel structures, while closed-loop platforms demonstrate early integration of prediction, synthesis, and robotic experimentation. However, major gaps remain: weak extrapolation beyond training distributions, inadequate handling of long-range interactions, poorly calibrated uncertainty quantification, limited synthesis prediction, underrepresentation of disordered materials, and insufficient experimental validation. Persistent unlearned lessons include benchmark biases that inflate generalization performance, poor reproducibility practices, misuse of invariant models for tensor properties, omission of random baselines in active learning, weak validity filtering in generative workflows, and near-absent failure reporting. This review critically assesses a decade of progress and shortcomings, grounded in 38 peer-reviewed publications. It highlights that hype around foundation models, generative inverse design, and autonomous labs often exceeds demonstrated impact. Realizing the field’s potential requires prioritizing extrapolation-focused architectures, mandatory experimental validation, shared failure registries, and stronger evidentiary standards to accelerate reliable discovery of functional materials.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2026 | Article: 72

Experimental Data Integration into ML Workflows for Real Alloys: A Review of Noisy, Sparse, and Heterogeneous Fusion
Integrating noisy, sparse, and heterogeneous experimental data with density functional theory (DFT) and machine learning (ML) is essential for reliable alloy design. While DFT enables high-throughput screening, its systematic biases limit predictive accuracy for real engineering alloys. This review synthesizes studies focused on fusing experimental measurements into ML–DFT workflows. We categorize five experimental data types—synthesis conditions, characterization data, property measurements, literature text, and industrial records—and identify six core challenges: noise, sparsity, heterogeneity, bias, missing metadata, and fragmentation. Six key integration strategies are examined: multi-fidelity learning, transfer learning, active learning with experimental feedback, Bayesian uncertainty modeling, multi-task learning, and physics-constrained augmentation. These approaches consistently reduce prediction errors by 30–60% compared to DFT-only models. Seven evidence-based best practices are distilled, emphasizing uncertainty reporting, data harmonization, experimental hold-out validation, and FAIR data sharing. Case studies demonstrate substantial gains in discovery efficiency for high-entropy alloys, superalloys, and phase diagrams. Remaining gaps, particularly the lack of standardized experimental databases and real-time feedback systems, are highlighted. This work provides a practical taxonomy and roadmap for developing experimentally grounded ML models that accelerate the design of high-performance alloys for aerospace, energy, and biomedical applications.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 January 2026 | Article: 75

From High-Throughput Computation to Autonomous Discovery: A Review of Closed-Loop Data Infrastructures in Materials Engineering
The field of materials engineering has undergone a profound transformation through the integration of high-throughput computation and data-driven methodologies, evolving from traditional trial-and-error approaches to sophisticated closed-loop systems that accelerate discovery. This review synthesizes recent advancements in computational and data-driven materials ecosystems, focusing on the infrastructure enabling autonomous discovery. Key elements include materials informatics platforms that leverage machine learning for property prediction and inverse design, graph neural networks for representation learning, and high-throughput computational workflows that generate multimodal datasets. We examine the progression from static high-throughput screening to dynamic, closed-loop paradigms incorporating active learning, uncertainty quantification, and simulation-experiment integration. Autonomous laboratories represent a pinnacle of this evolution, where AI orchestrates iterative cycles of hypothesis generation, experimentation, and refinement. The synthesis highlights how these infrastructures bridge computational predictions with experimental validation, fostering inverse materials design and optimizing resource allocation in complex chemical spaces. Challenges in data interoperability and model generalizability are noted, alongside prospects for scalable, self-optimizing systems. Overall, this review positions closed-loop data infrastructures as foundational to next-generation materials engineering, promising accelerated innovation in areas like energy storage, catalysis, and structural materials. By integrating diverse literature, we provide a systems-level perspective on how these tools are reshaping the discovery landscape.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 March 2022 | Article: 81

Representation Learning in Materials Science: Architectures, Data Modalities, and Discovery Applications
The field of materials science has undergone a transformative shift with the integration of computational and data-driven approaches, particularly through representation learning techniques that enable efficient handling of complex materials data. This review synthesizes recent advancements in architectures for representation learning, encompassing graph neural networks, attention-based models, and physics-inspired embeddings, which facilitate the extraction of meaningful features from diverse data modalities such as atomic structures, stoichiometries, and spectroscopic data. By bridging traditional computational methods with machine learning, these representations have accelerated property prediction, inverse design, and materials discovery applications, addressing challenges in high-dimensional spaces and sparse datasets. The scope of this narrative review covers the evolution from basic informatics to sophisticated multimodal integrations, highlighting how data ecosystems and learning frameworks contribute to autonomous discovery pipelines. A systems-level perspective is adopted to integrate cross-study insights, revealing synergies between representation learning and closed-loop systems that couple simulations with experiments. Looking ahead, the review posits that continued refinement of these architectures will drive scalable, AI-guided materials engineering, fostering innovations in energy, electronics, and structural materials while emphasizing the need for robust, interpretable models in real-world applications.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 March 2022 | Article: 82

Uncertainty Quantification in Computational Materials Engineering: Methods and Deployment Contexts
Computational materials engineering has undergone a transformative shift with the integration of data-driven methodologies and artificial intelligence, enabling accelerated discovery and design of novel materials. Uncertainty quantification (UQ) plays a pivotal role in this paradigm, addressing inherent variabilities in simulations, experimental data, and model predictions to ensure reliable decision-making in materials development. This review synthesizes recent advancements in UQ methods within computational and data-driven materials engineering, focusing on probabilistic modeling, sensitivity analysis, and Bayesian inference techniques deployed across multiscale simulations and machine learning frameworks. We examine deployment contexts ranging from molecular dynamics to additive manufacturing, highlighting how UQ enhances robustness in property prediction, process optimization, and autonomous discovery systems. By integrating insights from high-impact studies the review delineates a systems-level perspective on UQ infrastructures, emphasizing their role in bridging computational predictions with experimental validation. Key challenges such as computational efficiency and data scarcity are contextualized, alongside opportunities for multimodal integration. Ultimately, this synthesis positions UQ as an essential infrastructure for advancing materials informatics toward industrial applicability, offering a forward-looking outlook on scalable, uncertainty-aware workflows in materials engineering.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 March 2022 | Article: 83

Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering: High-Throughput Computational Screening Platforms, Workflows, and Discovery Outcomes
The field of computational and data-driven materials engineering has undergone rapid evolution, driven by advancements in high-throughput computational screening, machine learning algorithms, and integrated workflows that accelerate materials discovery. This review synthesizes recent developments in materials informatics, focusing on platforms that enable efficient exploration of vast chemical spaces through automated computations and data analytics. Key areas include the application of graph neural networks and representation learning for property prediction, active learning strategies to optimize experimental feedback loops, and the integration of multimodal datasets for enhanced model accuracy. High-throughput methods have facilitated discoveries in diverse domains, such as superconductors, battery materials, and high-entropy alloys, by combining density functional theory simulations with machine learning surrogates. Autonomous laboratories and closed-loop systems represent a paradigm shift, allowing self-driving experiments that minimize human intervention while maximizing discovery efficiency. Uncertainty quantification plays a critical role in guiding these processes, ensuring reliable predictions amid sparse data. This narrative review structures the landscape into computational ecosystems, workflow integrations, and discovery outcomes, highlighting cross-study synergies. It positions the field at the cusp of scalable, inverse design paradigms, where data-driven insights bridge simulation and experimentation to address grand challenges in materials science.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2023 | Article: 105

Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering: Multimodal Materials Datasets, Integration Frameworks, and Discovery Potential
The field of computational and data-driven materials engineering has transformed from traditional high-throughput simulations to sophisticated ecosystems integrating machine learning with multimodal datasets for accelerated discovery. This review synthesizes recent advancements in materials informatics, emphasizing the role of graph neural networks and deep learning in processing complex structural and property data. We examine multimodal datasets that combine experimental, computational, and textual modalities, enabling robust representation learning and uncertainty quantification. Integration frameworks are discussed, including active learning loops and multi-fidelity models that bridge simulation and experiment, addressing challenges like data sparsity and distribution shifts. The discovery potential is highlighted through applications in property prediction, inverse design, and autonomous systems, such as identifying stable alloys and energy materials. By providing an original synthesis of these elements, this article underscores the shift toward closed-loop workflows that enhance generalizability and interpretability, while identifying gaps in handling finite-temperature stability and disordered systems. Ultimately, these approaches promise to expand the known materials space by orders of magnitude, fostering innovations in sustainable technologies.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2023 | Article: 106

Data-Driven Materials Engineering: Inverse Design Strategies, Machine Learning Architectures, and Application Domains
The advent of data-driven approaches has revolutionized materials engineering, enabling inverse design strategies that prioritize target properties to guide material synthesis and optimization. This review synthesizes recent advancements in machine learning architectures tailored for materials informatics, including graph neural networks and representation learning frameworks that capture atomic-scale interactions and multiscale phenomena. We examine the integration of high-throughput computations with experimental workflows, highlighting closed-loop systems that incorporate active learning and uncertainty quantification to accelerate discovery. Key application domains span energy materials, metamaterials, and catalytic systems, where multimodal datasets facilitate simulation-experiment synergies. By analyzing computational ecosystems, we underscore the shift from forward modeling to inverse paradigms, emphasizing autonomous laboratories that iteratively refine hypotheses through data feedback loops. Challenges in generalizability and data scarcity are contextualized within broader systems integration, offering a cohesive perspective on how these tools reshape materials design. This narrative integrates cross-study insights to propose unified frameworks for scalable, data-centric engineering, bridging theoretical models with practical implementations in computational materials science.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2023 | Article: 107

Accountability Infrastructures in Closed-Loop Computational Materials Engineering
The rapid evolution of computational and data-driven materials engineering has introduced closed-loop systems that integrate simulation, machine learning, and experimental validation to accelerate materials discovery. However, these infrastructures raise critical questions about accountability, encompassing liability distribution across computational workflows, ownership of validation processes, attribution of errors in predictive models, and broader regulatory implications for deployment in high-stakes applications. This review synthesizes recent advancements in uncertainty quantification, error evaluation, and automated frameworks within computational materials ecosystems, highlighting how they underpin accountability mechanisms. We examine liability in multi-stage pipelines where uncertainties propagate from atomic simulations to macroscopic predictions, as seen in neural network potentials and Bayesian active learning approaches. Validation ownership is dissected through ensemble methods and adversarial techniques that assign responsibility for model reliability. Error attribution is explored via metrics and information-theoretic tools that trace discrepancies back to data sources or algorithmic biases. Regulatory considerations are framed around numerical quality controls and convergence protocols essential for certifying computational outputs in sectors like additive manufacturing and thermoelectric materials. By integrating cross-study insights, we propose an original interpretive structure for accountability infrastructures, emphasizing closed-loop feedback as a means to mitigate risks. This synthesis underscores the need for standardized protocols to ensure trustworthy integration of AI-driven tools in materials engineering, paving the way for ethical and reliable innovation.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2025 | Article: 134

Decision Authority Frameworks in Autonomous Materials Discovery Systems
The rapid evolution of computational and data-driven materials engineering has ushered in autonomous discovery systems that integrate machine learning, high-throughput simulations, and robotic experimentation to accelerate materials innovation. Central to these systems are decision authority frameworks, which define how authority is delegated between human operators and artificial intelligence agents, ensuring safe, ethical, and efficient operations. This review synthesizes recent literature on delegation models, human override mechanisms, responsibility assignment, and policy encoding within materials informatics ecosystems. We examine how these frameworks operate in closed-loop discovery pipelines, where active learning and uncertainty quantification guide iterative experimentation. Key areas include representation learning via graph neural networks for materials property prediction, multimodal dataset integration for simulation-experiment synergy, and inverse design strategies that balance exploration and exploitation. By analyzing delegation in autonomous laboratories, we highlight the role of human-in-the-loop paradigms in mitigating risks such as algorithmic bias or experimental failures. The review underscores the need for robust policy encodings that embed ethical constraints and regulatory compliance into AI-driven workflows. Drawing from high-impact studies, we provide an integrative perspective on how these frameworks enhance reliability in materials discovery, paving the way for scalable, trustworthy autonomous systems in computational materials science.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2025 | Article: 135

Governance Architectures for Self-Driving Laboratories in Computational Materials Engineering
The rapid evolution of computational and data-driven materials engineering has ushered in an era where self-driving laboratories (SDLs) promise to transform materials discovery by integrating automation, machine learning, and high-throughput experimentation into cohesive governance architectures. These architectures orchestrate the interplay between data generation, model training, and decision-making processes to enable closed-loop optimization in materials design. This review synthesizes recent advancements in SDL governance, focusing on how computational workflows—encompassing materials informatics, graph neural networks, representation learning, and uncertainty quantification—facilitate autonomous systems in addressing complex materials challenges. We examine the foundational elements of data-driven ecosystems, including multimodal datasets and simulation-experiment integration, and explore active learning strategies that balance exploration and exploitation in inverse design paradigms. Key governance components, such as orchestration platforms like ChemOS 2.0 and Bayesian active learning frameworks, are analyzed for their role in accelerating discovery cycles. By integrating perspectives from high-impact studies, we highlight how these architectures mitigate inefficiencies in traditional trial-and-error approaches, enabling scalable, reproducible materials innovation. The review positions SDL governance as a critical infrastructure for future materials engineering, emphasizing systems-level integration over isolated techniques. Ultimately, it underscores the potential of these architectures to democratize access to advanced materials development while identifying pathways for enhanced interoperability and robustness in computational ecosystems.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2025 | Article: 136

Institutional Oversight Models for AI-Directed Materials Innovation
The convergence of machine learning, high-throughput computation, and autonomous experimentation has transformed materials discovery into an AI-directed process capable of closed-loop, data-driven innovation at unprecedented speed. This narrative review examines the computational and data-driven materials engineering ecosystem, with a specific focus on the governance, regulatory, and institutional oversight frameworks required to steward these capabilities responsibly. We synthesize developments in materials informatics, representation learning, graph neural networks, active learning, uncertainty quantification, and simulation–experiment integration, showing how these tools have enabled autonomous laboratories and inverse design. Particular attention is given to community-driven calls for standards, explainability, and scientific responsibility that have emerged alongside the technology. By integrating technical literature with explicit discussions of data governance, reproducibility, and ethical deployment, we articulate the need for structured institutional oversight models that span standards bodies, regulatory readiness, and multi-stakeholder governance regimes. These models must operate at the infrastructure level—embedding accountability into discovery pipelines rather than retrofitting them. The review positions institutional oversight not as a constraint on innovation but as an essential enabler that ensures AI-directed materials engineering delivers safe, equitable, and societally beneficial outcomes.
Journal of Computational and Data-Driven Materials Engineering
Review | Open access | 18 September 2025 | Article: 137
Filters
Clear All





Access type